The Instrument as an Unintended Factor in Auditions
The Instrument as an Unintended Factor in Auditions Even when musicians are evaluated with complete integrity, audition conditions may introduce variables that adjudicators cannot fully control. In a symphony orchestra audition, two musicians may have nearly equivalent ability, technical skill, and experience, yet one may be assessed more favourably partly because of the instrument used. For example, Musician A may play an exceptional Stradivarius, while Musician B uses a competent but less distinguished instrument. The panel may hear greater richness, complexity, or projection from Musician A and attribute it to musicianship, when some of it may stem from the instrument itself. A superior instrument may also be more responsive and easier to play, requiring less effort to produce sound, dynamics, and expression, thereby enabling a wider expressive range with less exertion. This creates a methodological concern: the instrument’s advantage may be neither intentional nor fully ...